CARB Approves Carbon Credits for Clearcutting!!
On September 25, 2009 the California Air Resources Board (CARB) approved an addition to the
Forest Project Protocols allowing forest clearcutting as a rewardable forest management practice.
This new clearcutting paragraph is entirely inconsistent with, and explicitly contradicted by,
the definition of “natural forest management” in the same protocols, which requires forest
projects to “promote and maintain a diversity of native species and utilize management
practices that promote and maintain native forests comprised of multiple ages and mixed
native species at multiple landscape scales.” (Sec. 3.9.2). It is impossible for even-aged management,
particularly clearcutting, to meet those overarching requirements.
On September 30, 2009 it was made clear why this clearcutting provision had to be rushed into the protocols
as Sierra Pacific Industries (SPI) announced a multi-million dollar deal with a Equator,
a forest carbon brokage firm. SPI is the largest landowner and timber operator in Cailfornia
and is known for its widespread use of clearcutting in the Sierra Nevada and Northern California mountains.
Brian Nowicki of the Center for Biological Diversity is quoted on his characterization of this
deal, “This looks a whole lot like a giant timber company getting paid millions of dollars
to do business-as-usual, and destroying our forests, water quality, and wildlife in the process.
Giving carbon credits for logging operations is a shell game where timber companies win, and
the forest, the climate, and everyone else loses”.
We need to publicly keep this discussion alive!!
Please write letters to the editor: to
letters@mercurynews.com, to
letters@latimes.com. Letters to Chronicle should use this page
http://www.sfgate.com/chronicle/submissions/#1
for submission. LTEs should be less than 125 words and need to include your name and address.
Also, You can help by writing to Santa Clara County Supervisor Ken Yeager, who is on the Califonia
Air Resources Board which will continue to review this matter.
 
Supervisor Ken Yeager
 
County Govt. Center, E. Wing
 
70 W. Hedding St., 10th Fl.
 
San Jose, Calif. 95110
 
Phone: (408) 299-5040
 
email: Supervisor.Yeager@bos.sccgov.org
And other members of the Califonia Air Resources Board:
 
California Air Resources Board
 
1001 "I" Street
 
P.O. Box 2815
 
Sacramento, CA 95812
Press Releases
Official CARB Press Release on Forest Protocols
Conservation Group Press Release on Protocols
Sierra Club CA Letter to CARB
Carbon Sequestration & Forests
Link to CARB Forest Protocols
The Giving Trees
(Article from the National Resources Defense Coucil)
Forests as a storehouse for carbon
(From the US Forest Service)
E-zine Article on Sierra Nevada clearcuts
Myths about Clearcutting
Clearcutting Increases CO2
(From the Union of Concerned Scientists)
Tree Plantations are not Forests
(Sasaki, Nophea and Francis E. Putz. 2009)
Newspaper Coverage
San Jose Mercury News article on CARB Protocols vote
LA Times News article on SPI, Equator Deal
LA Times News article on CARB Protocols vote
Carbon Market Trade Journal Article
Sonora Union Democrat Article
NY Times Article on California Forest Protocols
SPI Announces Big Carbon Deal - Red Bluff Daily News
Audio of Humbolt State Redwoods Futures Conference
Sierra Pacific Industries' Clearcuts in El Dorado county
|